There is no natural mechanism inherent in the structure of such economies for inhibiting, much less reversing, that tendency. May 06, 2015 piketty maintains thomas piketty, capital in the twentyfirst century, trans. Thomas piketty, capital in the twentyfirst century. Ann cudd is professor of philosophy and dean of arts and sciences at boston university. A critique of piketty on the normative force of wealth inequality. Arthur goldhammer, capital in the twenty first century belknap press of harvard university press, 2014. Essay to serve is to rule, by doug henwood harpers magazine. Piketty s most recent volume, published in french in 20, and in english in 2014 as capital in the twentyfirst century a knowing nod to karl marx is a sprawling, ambitious text that builds on this. Thomas pikettys capital in the twentyfirst century has succeeded both commercially and as a work of scholarship. May 17, 2015 if this seems so clearly the case with grief, it is only because it was already the case with desire. Jan 04, 2016 piketty, rousseau, and the desire for inequality. Heres a guy who was a natural for cranking out theoretical models in economics. But the major frustration of the book is political.
Doug henwood published the left business observer from 1986 to 20 and hosts a weekly radio show on kpfa, berkeley. A historical and international perspective natl bureau of econ. Galbraith, robert paul wolff, paul krugman, robert m. The quarterly journal of economics,february 2003 1. As state violations of political rights garnered attention, a commitment to material equality disappeared and market fundamentalism emerged as the dominant economic force. Arthur goldhammer, capital in the twentyfirst century belknap press of harvard university press, 2014. Apr 28, 2014 minnesota mafia challenges piketty let me begin by noting that i have as yet been unable to obtain a copy and so have not read piketty s smash hit book yet. Capital in the twentyfirst century by thomas piketty. Thomas piketty and ryan grim ajay kumar and myles udland doug henwood start with ryan grim. Dec 17, 2015 piketty, meade and predistribution by martin oneill on december 17, 2015 thomas pikettys capital in the twentyfirst century presents a troubling puzzle for social democrats and for parties of the centreleft, as well as for academics interested in developing a more egalitarian public policy agenda. If international tax competition prevents this policy change from happening, one cannot exclude the development of a new wave of antiglobalization and anticapital policies. The upshot is that money begets money, and the more money the more begetting henwood. See henwood, the top of the world, bookforum, aprilmay 2014 accessed at.
Further, because s and g are largely determined by di. Oct 01, 2014 the foreign account tax compliance act fatca was passed in 2010 as part of the hiring incentives to restore employment act, pub. Pikettys unlikely path ive only just started k21, so i wont comment on anything substantive, but the miniautobiography he presents in the introduction got me thinking. Cxviii february 2003 issue1 income inequality in the united states, 191998 thomaspikettyandemmanuelsaez this paper presents new homogeneous series on top shares of income and wages from 19 to 1998 in the united states using individual tax returns data. Economist doug henwood points out that it would be quite easy to make higher education completely free. Why we ignore the facts that will save us booker t.
The debate over secular stagnation started by larry summers and paul krugman continues on. French economist thomas piketty caused a sensation in early 2014 with his book on a simple, brutal formula explaining economic inequality. Spodaj so dokumenti s prosojnicami z vaj v obliki ms powerpoint oz. Capitals empirical research is widely praised among economistseven by those who disagree with its policy prescriptions. Supported by a previously unimagined wealth of statistical detail, gained through the archival labour over many years of a large team of researchers, pikettys.
Doug henwood s radio archives through december 2016 lbo editor doug henwood does a radio show on wbai, new york, covering economics and politics. Further, because s and g are largely determined by. Radical political economy blog hub of the union for. Minnesota mafia challenges piketty let me begin by noting that i have as yet been unable to obtain a copy and so have not read pikettys smash hit book yet. Aug 30, 20 thomas piketty, capital in the twentyfirst century this is one of those scholarly books that seem to end up being accidental cultural markers of time and place. Doug henwood, who often has so many intelligent and useful things to say about economics and politics, has it wrong this time. They include, beside the oversigned, david colander, edward fullbrook who must be credited for the whole issue, james k. Yet thomas pikettys capital in the twentyfirst century hereafter cittfc has been embraced by thoughtful readers across the ideological spectrum and from varied walks of life. Instead id like to note some key elements of content and style, which might be useful for other current or wouldbe readers. Samuel moyn asks why we chose not to challenge wealth and neglected the demands of a broader social and economic justice. Here are some archived shows, as well as some individual interviews. Essay to serve is to rule, by doug henwood harpers. Debt as power the bichler and nitzan archives york university.
If you prefer the oldfashioned way, you can mail a check payable to left business observer to doug henwood, lbo, 38 greene st 4th fl, new york ny 1002505. Aug 11, 2011 economist doug henwood points out that it would be quite easy to make higher education completely free. Piketty for dummies1 geoff bertram june 2014 piketty in three sentences. The american response to thomas pikettys new book on inequality has been. Here, he talks through the massive data set that led him to conclude. There is no natural mechanism inherent in the structure of such economies.
Inequality in the long run university of california, berkeley. Piketty maintains thomas piketty, capital in the twentyfirst century, trans. The age of human rights has been kindest to the rich. Thomas piketty, in his new book, capital in the twentyfirst century, makes clear that the experience of postwar america and the rest of the developed world was a historical anomaly. Its always dangerous to project current trends into the future, but heres one extrapolation ill subscribe to. English capital in the twentyfirst century thomas piketty. I dont do much with figures now i dont smoke absence of. Solow, mike konczal, thomas frank, seth ackerman, mike beggs, david harvey.
Consider doug henwoods description of thomas pikettys main theme in his new book capital which i havent read yet. At the nation, read an excerpt from not enough arguing that the emergence of a humanrights framework should not serve as an excuse to abandon the fight against economic inequality. Free quote search engine ethics, values, and wisdom. Professional economists seldom write best sellers, especially not with books that contain extensive references to academic arguments. It sounds like thomas piketty, who is french, has written an important book about the trends of distribution of wealth and income in 20 th21 st century economies, primarily in developed economies. Galbraith, michael hudson, richard koo, richard parker, ann pettifor, and robert wade see below for links to their papers. His most recent book, my turn, was based on his november 2014 cover story for harpers magazine, stop hillary. The general story is that the natural rate of accumulation of capital is on the order of fivesix percent. The core message of this enormous and enormously important book can be delivered in a few lines. The economic logic of a capitalist market system with private wealth plus inheritance leads to a highly unequal, but stable, social order with a patrimonial rentier class at the top. In a recent seminar in ct, i came across this article by j. Capital in the twentyfirst century ladislau dowbor. Apr 20, 2014 pikettys unlikely path ive only just started k21, so i wont comment on anything substantive, but the miniautobiography he presents in the introduction got me thinking. Contributions from jared bernstein, dean baker, and daniel davies are worth reading as are plenty im missing, for sure the root question being discussed is whether or not the shortfall in aggregate demand that drove the great recession and continues to depress the u.
At the same time, the share of income going to the top 10 percent of wage earners reached an alltime high of 47. In debate over secular stagnation, dont let legitimate. Red egg gallery spirituality, communitarianism, art, and great photos my friends blog. Thomas piketty s capital in the twentyfirst century presents a troubling puzzle for social democrats and for parties of the centreleft, as well as for academics interested in developing a more egalitarian public policy agenda. Download thomas piketty capital in the twentyfirst. I have spent a lot of time on piketty s capital21 which was fascinating but i got only glimpses of parts of it. Doug henwood, a journalist for left business observer, who is. The more persistent trend, he found, was a rise in inequality when the rate of return on capital the major source of income for the wealthiest. The piketty phenomenon and the future of inequality realworld. Economics and finance ledocs world a prickly expat. Galbraith, michael hudson, richard koo, richard parker, ann pettifor, and robert wade.
I think it is the most diverse, deep, and farreaching quotation search engine on values, ethics, and wisdom anywhere. Whether this social order is compatible with democracy depends on what a democratic. It may be that one wants to, or does, but it may also be that despite ones best efforts, one is undone, in the face of the other, by the touch, by the scent, by the feel, by the prospect of the touch, by the memory of the feel. This does not, however, imply that kuznetshypothesis is no longer of interest. Special issue on pikettys capital pdf issue 69, 7 october 2014, 182 p. Aside from the change in, everything else is exactly as in the paperback edition. Doug henwood bookforum 20140401 how does a rigorous, sevenhundred page economic history become a lionized hit. Despite their modest critiques, pikettys work has been embraced by doug hen wood and paul krugman among other sophisticated analysts of economic matters.
Piketty 2001a, 2001b, in addition to the top decile denoted by. Apparently piketty will respond to the seminar in january next year. The participants with links to their responses are below. Doug henwood soaking the rich is a great start but its not enough we should be clear about what it will take to fund a decent welfare state. Dodane so tudi povsem nakljucno in nesistematicno izbrane povezave do nekaterih del, ki jih omenjamo na vajah, ali do besedil, ki so povezana z vsebinami vaj. Income and wealth inequality was very high a century ago, particularly in europe, but dropped dramatically in the first half of the 20th century. Hes working on a book about the rot of the american ruling class. Capital in the twentyfirst century convinces because piketty supports his arguments about inequality with two innovative forms of evidence largely neglected by his predecessors on both the left and the right. Doug henwood in book forum sums up pikettys argument like. The personal share of about 1 percent of gross domestic product is a third of. Starting with the title, the eternally recurrent specter of marx hangs over this book. It is original and very important, and deserves a wide audience. Listen to samuel moyn discuss not enough on kpfa berkeley, cas behind the news with doug henwood. Why pikettys book is a bigger deal in america than in france the.
Pikettys capital, link roundup a budding sociologist. We have finished publishing our seminar on thomas piketty. Mason its bargaining power all the way down which seems clearer than most. Left to its own devices, wealth inevitably tends to concentrate in capitalist economies. The first is an unprecedented trove of historical economic data, which piketty uses to demonstrate increasing inequality due to the long. Thomas pikettys capital in the twentyfirst century presents a troubling puzzle for social democrats and for parties of the centreleft, as well as for academics interested in developing a more egalitarian public policy agenda. This chapter covers the range of instruments traded on wall street, such as stocks, bonds, derivatives, currencies etc. Arthur goldhammer cambridge, mass harvard university press, 2014. Doug henwoods radio archives left business observer. If this seems so clearly the case with grief, it is only because it was already the case with desire. The piketty phenomenon and the future of inequality 2. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
This entry was posted on thursday, march 29th, 2007 at 11. Im pretty sure piketty wanted his book to be readdiscusseddebated, and belnapharvard press certainly wanted it to be bought. At new humanist, read professor moyns argument that the critical reason human rights have. Through the canny voice of professor thomas piketty, and his demystification of inherited wealth, karl marxs true legacy, and what we mean when we talk about monetary growth and inequality. Download thomas piketty capital in the twentyfirst century. Inequality in the long run university of california. Doug henwoods radio archives through december 2016 lbo editor doug henwood does a radio show on wbai, new york, covering economics and politics. Economic inequality is not new, but it is getting worse, with radical possible impacts. You can follow any responses to this entry through the rss 2. Published on the web by doug henwood in 2005 under a creative commons license.
Doug henwood in book forum sums up pikettys argument like this. Doug henwood, a return to a world marx would have known. Why we never think alone hugo mercier the enigma of reason sara e. Pikettys most recent volume, published in french in 20, and in english in 2014 as capital in the twentyfirst century a knowing nod to karl marx is a sprawling, ambitious text that builds on this. I have spent a lot of time on pikettys capital21 which was fascinating but i got only glimpses of parts of it. A snippet from henwood on picketys failure to connect his research to a solution that would save us from serfdom.
How it works and for whom steven sloman the knowledge illusion. Paul krugman hailed the book in the new york times, 23 mar. If that is the case, capital taxation may increase in years to come as the trend of increasing inequality continues. As the title indicates, this book is an introduction to wall street how it works and for whom. The whole seminar is available on the www here if you prefer to read the seminar in pdf form, its available here if you would like the raw latex file for the seminar e. Henry farrell is an associate professor of political science and international affairs at george washington university. However, i think that i know enough about what is in it to post on this particular matter. And an ft piece on crimeanomics and sanctions leverage.
1192 785 1210 1474 726 414 595 33 791 56 577 1587 374 769 1620 653 274 622 925 467 1434 272 732 673 423 865 202 371 1476 1599 1120 8 1136 883 749 38 1104